How a burner phone and motorcycle purchase led to conviction in Ohio couple's murder

Tom and Angela Strussions' killer was brought to justice after five years.

When neighbors saw smoke wafting from Tom and Angela Strussion's Ohio home one morning in 2021, they knew something was wrong.

Authorities responded to the scene, but they didn't discover evidence of an uncontrolled blaze. Instead, they found that the Strussions had been murdered.

A new "20/20" episode, "Murder on the Menu," airing Friday, Nov. 20 at 9 p.m. ET on ABC and streaming the next day on Disney+ and Hulu, examines the case.

You can get more behind the scenes of each week's episode by listening to "20/20: The After Show" weekly series right on your 20/20 podcast feed on Mondays, hosted by "20/20" co-anchor Deborah Roberts.

Tom and Angela Strussion were murdered in their home on the morning of Sept. 21, 2021.
Courtesy Lisa Balog

Tom and Angela were well-known in their community as the owners of a local Tex-Mex restaurant called Salsa Joe's. Tom opened the original location in Texas, where the couple met and got married in 2016. They moved to Tom's hometown of Belmont, Ohio, to be closer to his family and to open a new restaurant location.

"So if I could describe Tommy with one word, it would be 'magnetic,'" family friend Sara Kirby told "20/20.""You meet him, and you're just drawn to him, his personality. He's so outgoing, so fun."

And Angela, Kirby said, was a grounding presence for Tom.

"Angela was just [a] beauty," Kirby said. "She was beautiful inside and out. She was quiet if you didn't know her, but very outgoing once you got to know her."

On the morning of Sept. 21, 2021, everything changed. Authorities responded to several 911 calls at about 7 a.m., and an initial assessment determined Tom and Angela died of multiple gunshot wounds.

Sara Kirby, Tom and Angela Strussions' friend, remembered the couple in an interview with ABC News.
ABC News

Detectives found origins of multiple fires that were set throughout the home as well, which produced the smoke witnessed by neighbors. All three of the Strussions' pets died of apparent smoke inhalation.

The fires had deposited soot, contributing to the difficulty of analyzing DNA evidence at the crime scene. Other life-saving attempts complicated authorities' ability to obtain DNA evidence, including the pumping of bleach water into the home and first responders' fingerprints left on the scene.

Investigators tried to obtain security or doorbell camera video footage, but neighbors' cameras did not capture the suspect.

With no DNA matches or video camera evidence, investigators began to dig into the couple's past to identify suspects.

After nearly two and a half years without a successful lead, detectives started over and reinvestigated a former business partner of Tom and Angela's, giving new life to the case.

Authorities determined that multiple fires were set in Tom and Angela Strussions' home around the time of their murders.
Belmont County Prosecutors Office

Four months before the Strussions were murdered, they invested tens of thousands of dollars in a new Salsa Joe's location. According to a signed agreement later presented in court, they held a 50-50 stake with a man named Andrew Griffin, who moved to Ohio from Oklahoma to help with the launch.

Despite a strong start, the new Salsa Joe's location began losing money. Griffin allegedly left for weeks at a time and failed to pay bills and vendors. Tom and Angela decided to shut down the restaurant four months after it had opened, leaving Griffin with very little return on his investment.

Cell phone records indicated that Griffin's phone showed activity in and around his home in Oklahoma during the time of murders. But when they attempted to call him years later to ask more questions, Griffin dodged their calls. Investigators went to Oklahoma, only to learn that he had gone to Mexico, then to Costa Rica.

Authorities questioned Griffin's wife, Stacee, who initially denied knowledge of the murders. Later, investigators said, she told them that Griffin had admitted to her that he murdered Tom and Angela. Stacee said she was divorcing Griffin and that she had at first withheld information because she feared for her own safety.

Andrew Griffin at trial for the murders of Tom and Angela Strussion in October 2026.
ABC News

Stacee told investigators that Griffin had used a revolver to kill the Strussions and drove a motorcycle to and from the crime scene, authorities said.

After tracking the sale of the motorcycle and calls to a burner phone, investigators felt as though they had enough information. They arrested Griffin for arson and the murders of Tom and Angela Strussion. He pleaded not guilty to the charges.

Griffin's trial ended in November 2026.

A friend of his testified that Griffin traveled to and from the house on the motorcycle, continuously demanded that Tom give him money, and then killed the couple with the revolver. He had left his real phone in Oklahoma with him during the murder to avoid suspicion, the friend said.

Michele Odena, Angela Strussion's sister, waited for years for authorities to arrest her sister's alleged murderer.
ABC News

Earlier this month, the jury found Griffin guilty of four counts of aggravated murder and one count of aggravated arson. He will be sentenced on Dec. 1. He told "20/20" that he plans on appealing his conviction.

Family and friends described the conviction as a relief and remembered the legacy of Tom and Angela.

"[I] just miss his presence all the time, but I still feel it around me all the time too. Every time I get a certain sign, 'Oh, that's from Tommy,'" Lisa Balog, his sister, said.

Michele Odena, Angela's sister, said she remembered her as someone who "felt things really deeply."

"If she loved you, she loved you wholeheartedly," she told "20/20." "She attached to you. You were hers. And I loved that about her."

Related Topics

Sponsored Content by Taboola